17 Camels and 3 Sons

The Story of 17 Camels and 3 Sons

Long ago, in a quiet village near the desert, an old man lived with his three sons. Their livelihood came from the 17 camels he owned, which he rented out for desert transport. When the old man passed away, his sons gathered to read his will. He had divided all his property evenly—except for the camels. His instructions said:

• The eldest son should receive ½ of the camels
• The middle son should receive ⅓
• The youngest son should receive ¹⁄₉

The sons stared at each other in confusion. How do you divide 17 camels into halves, thirds, and ninths without cutting any camel apart? They argued, calculated, and worried for days, but no solution made sense. Finally, they went to the wise man of the village.

After hearing their problem, the wise man smiled and asked them to bring him all 17 camels. Then he added one camel of his own, making the total 18. Now with an even number of Camels, the three sons divided them accordingly:

• The eldest son to took his share: ½ of 18 = 9 camels
• The middle son took his share: ⅓ of 18 = 6 camels
• The youngest son took his share: ¹⁄₉ of 18 = 2 camels

Upon dividing the 18 Camels they realized that 9 + 6 + 2 = 17 camels. All 17 camels were distributed exactly as their father wished. And the wise man simply took back his own camel—the 18th camel. The problem was solved without harming a single camel.

The Moral of the Story

Sometimes, the solution to a problem isn’t found by dividing what you have… but by adding something extra—a new idea, a new perspective, or a temporary resource. Problems may seem as though they have no solution, but when you’re willing to think differently, most problems and arguments can be resolved.